Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> completely derailing their career path, halting all research

That's a real odd way to characterize a person's death.



I don't think they meant it in a negative way. The last line makes me think they mean it in a sort of self-reflective butterfly effect way.

Similar to how anyone might reflect on how the death of a relative or friend ultimately led them to being the person they are now in some way.


[flagged]


My point is that text doesn't necessarily convey how they meant it. Their experience of the advisor's passing was indirect, so it isn't all that crazy that what stands out to them is how it affected their SO and the obvious effect it'd have had on the advisor's family.


That's because I'm me and not anyone else. It was pretty traumatic for my SO and everyone else around the PI. The PI insisted on going into work and continuing on like nothing changed even as they were mentally deteriorating. If I don't include details about the tragedy it might be because I don't want to bring that energy to my comment and not because I somehow was oblivious to their significance.


There was nothing at all wrong with your comment.


Detailing the impact a death has on the surrounding family and person's work as a personal account is fine. Your criticism is what's weird here.


Why are you being so dramatic? Life is short, let it go


Read the sentence again, more slowly this time.


It’s still odd to characterize a person’s death in terms of someone else’s career progression. Probably because it’s uncommon to see a death characterized by it’s second order effects. Usually it’s the family or friends and it’s more personal. OP didn’t say anything wrong though.


> It’s still odd to characterize a person’s death in terms of someone else’s career progression.

OP even went another level, since it was their SO's career progression that was affected, thus affecting OP. Agreed, they're not wrong, but it was odd.


They’re not wrong in the sense they’re factually correct: OP’s life would have been different had a cure been available. But if OP’s SO approached her PI on their deathbed and said “Dear PI, what about my SO?” They’d probably be met with incredulity.


Well it is a good thing that nothing like that happened then, isn’t it?


PI = ?


Principal investigator. It’s what phd students call their academic advisor/boss during graduate school


Probably Principal Investigator. I'd guess the "SO" is a PhD student and now his/her program is up in the air.


Significant Other.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: