Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I am willing to hear you out on this, but the Pentagon employs a lot of personnel, can you demonstrate that the sentiment you describe was actually representative?

Clearly those who do believe in this intervention don't have the same incentive to speak up as those that disagree with it.

It is also rather vague to conflate warnings with disagreement:

They can believe in the validity of an approach but still have the legal obligation to not just inform the president of the values and benefits of such a mission, but also warn him of any potential negative outcomes.

Warning someone about a path of action, is not equivalent to disagreeing with that path of action, it can be their job description to provide such warnings.

That said, I would like to read more about what you are referring to, to make sure we are talking about the same things.




From your own source:

> Joint Chiefs Chairman Gen. Dan Caine has been advising President Trump and top officials that a military campaign against Iran could carry significant risks, in particular the possibility of becoming entangled in a prolonged conflict, according to two sources with knowledge of those internal discussions.

"that a military campaign against Iran could carry significant risks, "

specifically

"could carry"

Sounds like people doing their job, and informing a president of potential outcomes, precisely what I predicted above. The media always makes things seem more adversarial than what it turns out to be.


Your comments make it clear that you are a propagandist and maybe even a bot. I assume that you can comprehend English, but are choosing to be obtuse. If that is not the case, and you still cannot understand the warnings, ask Claude or some other AI to help you.


[flagged]


https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47471826

Iran doesn't have nukes and had agreed to never build any, they fully complied with all audits.

You seem extremely confused, its really strange why you aren't demanding completely bombing and destroying the actual nukes in the only Middle Eastern country that has illegal nukes.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: