Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Interesting! If someone with a math background (but not a CS background) wanted to dig deep into learning about mesh networking protocol theory - do you have any recommendations for learning resources or places to get started?

I've long imagined that a content centric mesh network approach would be a better starting point than what we've built up currently, but it seems like such a deep and mysterious subject and I have no idea where to even begin to get started.



I never followed where things went after the contract was complete. Suffice it to say that we only cared about getting the protocol working, as the company was a contract engineering firm doing work for a product that was ultimately for military use. Actually testing it in the real world and improving behaviour was out of scope. We only tested it in a simulated network to make sure that the protocol correctly handled various cases (like certain wireless nodes not being able to see each other due to obstructions).

I had other friends back in the early 2000s working on WiMax, and the hardest part of their work was getting QoS right. More recently (still 10+ years ago), another friend implemented a TCP proxy for a major cell phone provider in the US that used a more wireless friendly congestion control protocol on the wireless network side of things as regular TCP breaks down when latency increases due to reception issues (which gets interpreted as congestion and triggers retransmits). Since the cellular base stations ensured that the wireless network was effectively lossless (albeit with periods of much higher latency), performance for end users increased substantially when the bulk of the TCP retransmits were suppressed.

There's a huge gap between making wireless work vs making it work well. For me, 5G is a step backwards as all the tricks used to push for higher data rates (like larger QAM constellations) make everything worse in rural areas with poor reception: there just isn't a good enough SNR 99% of the time for the new shiny, and the increased power usage does nothing other than drain my phone's battery faster than it did with older LTE. But that is where all the money for research is today.

Wireless is complicated.


It highly depends on where you plan to run your mesh on. Meshes that one run on wired networks (be it copper or fiber) are vastly different from meshes that work on radio waves. Even more different when it comes to this radio spectrum.

If you're talking about fast and low latency connection then look into existing meshes, almost every popular mesh has some sort of paper describing how it works.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: