Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Because recognizing a prime number using an actual regular expression would prove that prime numbers form a regular language, which would be an incredible result.

And somehow, some people like me are in computer science mode when reading such sentences, such reminders wakes us up: "Oh, ok, not actually regular, not such a big deal"



> Because recognizing a prime number using an actual regular expression would prove that prime numbers form a regular language, which would be an incredible result.

It would be literally incredible, because the pumping lemma shows that it's false.


> because the pumping lemma shows that it's false

Ah yes, I even used to teach this actually. Sorry for the understatement xD.


> Ah yes, I even used to teach this actually. Sorry for the understatement xD.

No worries! Mainly I was just pleased with myself for remembering the pumping lemma, and kind of wished that I knew how to contact my professor (from back in the mid-1990s, when an intro CS course was taught out of Sipser and involved almost no actual programming) and tell him that he did such a good job that it stuck with me some 30 years later!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: