Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Oh yeah like the ubiquitous "buzzing alarm clock", crap like that should literally not be legal.


In some places it isn't.

It's a social issue and you should petition for the change you'd like to see.

For example in the UK, advertisers must comply with the Advertising Standards Authority code [1], and section 4 includes:

> Radio only – Advertisements must not include sounds that are likely to create a safety hazard, for example, to those listening to the radio while driving.

Which while open to interpretation, this would likely include any sirens likely to be confused with a genuine siren.

Or:

> Television only – Advertisements must not be excessively noisy or strident.

( That one might raise an eyebrow to anyone familiar with the long running "Go Compare" campaign! )

Of course these codes are always written in a way that's woolly and often adverts are only banned after complaints have been made.

But the framework is there for standards to be written and upheld. It relies however on people being willing to put in time and effort to complain when standards are broken, and there needs to be effort made to tighten those standards in some areas to stop standards slipping, although in general standards have been tightened rather than loosened over the years.

If your experience is very different, consider that it may be worth spending time organising a campaign group to lobby the FTC (or FCC?) to tighten their rules, or organise a group to put in complaints to organisations which have similar "voluntary" codes such as the BBB and also pressure the BBB to tighten their rules to have guidelines prohibiting such noises.

Change doesn't happen for change sake, it requires organisation and action, but even a handful of people can effect huge change with a concerted effort.

[1] https://www.asa.org.uk/codes-and-rulings/advertising-codes/b...


Nice, yup that's a great point. Here in Canada it would be the CRTC. Yeah, I could write them. I've reported spam and related stuff to them before but got no response. Perhaps things are different in the marketing/advertising side of things. Guess I'll just have to find out! :)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: