>Another reason for requiring feedback for downvoting is so others know why it was downvoted
That will just lead to bickering. And really if that's the rule then you should also be forced to make a meaningful comment when upvoting.
I find that there are times to downvote that don't or shouldn't require a comment. It will just spiral into a comment war tit for tat comments spiraling down into a hundred levels.
> I find that there are times to downvote that don't or shouldn't require a comment. It will just spiral into a comment war tit for tat comments spiraling down into a hundred levels.
I'd be interesting to hear some examples. The only instances that sprung to my mind were instances where posts probably should be flagged instead anyway. However I'm open to the possibility I've overlooked some scenarios (as well as the possibility that flagging might get abused as a way of voting without commenting)
That will just lead to bickering. And really if that's the rule then you should also be forced to make a meaningful comment when upvoting.
I find that there are times to downvote that don't or shouldn't require a comment. It will just spiral into a comment war tit for tat comments spiraling down into a hundred levels.